The Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) opened in Geneva on Nov. 16, and its opening session was suspended before an agenda was adopted. Russia refused to adopt the agenda until observers, including the European Union and campaign groups, were barred from speaking in most sessions, and the conference's Swiss president suspended the session, DroneXL reported.
Once the procedural fight is settled, delegates face the main question: should the CCW start negotiating rules for lethal autonomous weapons systems, and if it does, should those rules be binding? According to the Associated Press, the conference could decide this week whether to launch negotiations. The United States has put a slower, voluntary path on the table, and it differs sharply from the plan in the chair's own draft.
Two Texts, Two Timelines
The proposals on the table differ on three points: what the result should be, how fast it should come, and whether it binds anyone.
The US working paper, dated Nov. 4, asks for a five-year mandate. Under it, a group of experts would meet 10 days a year and draft a non-binding instrument, adopted by consensus. Version 1.0 would come in 2029, updates would follow in 2030 and 2031, and the group would report to the next review conference in 2031, per DroneXL. The paper argues that a voluntary text can be updated as the technology changes and applies to every state at once, while a protocol binds only the states that ratify it. It also says the voluntary text would be "without prejudice" to a future consensus decision to change its nature, so a later protocol is not ruled out.
The chair's draft takes a different line. Ambassador Elmer Schialer Salcedo of Peru circulated it on Oct. 23. Its one-page proposal tells the expert group to "negotiate a new Protocol to the Convention," meet 15 days a year, and hand a draft protocol to the 2028 meeting of member states, DroneXL reported. A protocol is a treaty-level instrument; the AP notes that governments have already struck a deal to regulate blinding lasers under the convention.
A third proposal came last month from seven countries: Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama. It calls for launching negotiations on a legally binding agreement, the AP reported.
Put side by side, the gap is large. The chair's plan aims at a draft protocol by 2028, with more meeting days per year, and it ends in a legal instrument. The US plan runs five years with fewer meeting days, and it ends in guidance that states can choose to follow. Under the US timeline, nothing reaches a review conference until 2031.
The Consensus Problem
The CCW takes decisions by consensus, and DroneXL noted that any one of its 128 member states can stop either plan. The AP likewise says any single country can thwart an agreement and that any deal is likely to be based on a low common denominator. The opening-day dispute over observers shows how much procedure alone can slow the talks.
Rules are popular in general. Stop Killer Robots says 130 countries support new international rules on autonomous weapons, the AP reported, and UN Secretary-General António Guterres has set a deadline this year for the launch of talks. But the US and Russia want to limit any curbs on their ability to develop and deploy these systems, according to the AP, and Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova called it "premature" to argue that the time has come for restrictive or prohibitive measures.
That leaves the majority with two poor options. It can accept a weaker mandate that all 128 states will sign off on, or it can push for a stronger one and risk getting no mandate at all. The US paper offers a route that consensus rules can accommodate: a voluntary text, written slowly, by agreement.
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has put its weight on the other side. "States must act to ensure the future of warfare is not handed over to machines," ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric said in a statement on Friday, as quoted by the AP.
Meanwhile, in Washington
US domestic policy has been moving faster than its Geneva position. On June 5, 2026, the White House issued National Security Presidential Memorandum 11 (NSPM-11), "Artificial Intelligence in the National Security Enterprise." Section 3(a) directs the Secretary of War to issue an update to DoD Directive 3000.09, Autonomy in Weapon Systems, within 90 days, and to review it annually after that. DroneXL reported that no revised version had been made public as of Nov. 16.
Directive 3000.09 is the US rule on autonomous weapons. The memorandum frames the push this way: it says previous administrations "imposed undue bureaucracy that hampered the pace of AI adoption," and it argues that competitors are deploying autonomous technologies "with little regard for appropriate human oversight or civil liberties."
Separately, Secretary Pete Hegseth ordered an Autonomous Warfare Command to be standing by Oct. 1, 2027, DroneXL reported.
Read together, the two tracks point the same way. At home, the administration is moving quickly on a directive that is to be reviewed every year to keep up with the technology. Abroad, it wants any international text to be voluntary, agreed by consensus, and delivered in stages, with a first version no earlier than 2029.
Why It Matters
For the drone and UAS community, these talks are not abstract. Two questions are open: what counts as acceptable human control, and who writes that definition.
If Geneva adopts the chair's mandate, a draft protocol would be due by 2028, and treaty language could eventually limit how autonomous systems are designed, tested and sold. If the US approach wins, the 2020s would most likely end with a voluntary code. Each state would interpret it for itself, and national policy, such as the rewritten Directive 3000.09, would do much of the real regulating. If the conference produces neither, the seven-nation push for a binding agreement and the Secretary-General's deadline would be left without a clear venue.
For manufacturers and program offices, the practical point is this: under the US proposal, binding international rules on autonomous weapons are unlikely to arrive this decade. The rules that matter in the near term will be set in national directives, and the US is rewriting its own.
Sources
- US Asks UN For Five Years To Write Voluntary Killer Robot Rules (DroneXL, Nov. 16, 2026)
- NSPM-11, Artificial Intelligence in the National Security Enterprise (White House, June 5, 2026)
- Killer drones face a reckoning as UN conference of nations considers rules on lethal AI weapons (Associated Press via News4JAX, Nov. 16, 2026)